How to Spot & Avoid Common Car Buying Scams

Cargatic • January 3, 2025

Buying a car can be an exciting experience, but it also comes with its fair share of challenges—especially for first-time buyers or anyone venturing into online car shopping. Scammers often target eager buyers, preying on their inexperience or urgency to secure a deal. The good news? With the right knowledge and a watchful eye, you can confidently steer clear of car buying scams and ensure you get the vehicle you deserve.


This guide will help you recognize red flags, learn key scam prevention tactics, and make informed decisions to avoid becoming a victim.


Common Car Buying Scams to Watch Out For

By familiarizing yourself with the tactics scammers use, you’ll be better prepared to spot suspicious activity. Here are some of the most common scams in car buying:


1. The Too-Good-To-Be-True Scam

Imagine finding an incredible deal on a car—well below market value, in excellent condition, and with all the perks you’re looking for. While this seems like a dream come true, it’s often a red flag. Scammers use appealing prices to lure unsuspecting buyers into paying for a vehicle that doesn’t exist.

Red Flag: The seller pushes for quick payment or refuses to meet in person.

How to Avoid It:

  • Research the car's market value using trusted platforms like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds.
  • Be wary of deals that seem significantly underpriced without a reasonable explanation.


2. Title Washing

Scammers may sell a vehicle with a hidden history of damage—such as being salvaged or totaled—by altering or “washing” the title to make it appear clean.

Red Flag: The seller is reluctant to provide a vehicle history report or VIN (Vehicle Identification Number).

How to Avoid It:

  • Always request and review a Carfax or AutoCheck report to verify the car's history.
  • Use the VIN to verify the title’s authenticity through your local Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV).


3. Online Payment Scams

Digital payments are meant to offer convenience, but they can also be exploited by scammers. They may request wire transfers, cryptocurrency, or obscure third-party payment methods that make tracking or reversing payments difficult.

Red Flag: The seller strongly insists on wire transfers or unusual payment methods.

How to Avoid It:

  • Stick to secure and traceable payment methods like PayPal for Goods and Services or bank checks.
  • Avoid payments before physically inspecting the vehicle.


4. Fake Escrow Services

Escrow services are designed to protect both buyers and sellers, but fake escrow websites or services impersonating legitimate ones can be used to defraud buyers.

Red Flag: A seller suggests using an escrow service that seems unfamiliar or poorly designed.

How to Avoid It:

  • Only use verified, well-known escrow services to facilitate payments.
  • Look up reviews and check the official website for contact details and legitimacy.


5. Odometer Fraud

Some sellers tamper with the car’s odometer to make it appear as though the vehicle has lower mileage than it actually does. This scam increases the car's market value deceptively.

Red Flag: Signs of odometer tampering, such as inconsistent wear and tear on pedals or seats for the reported mileage.

How to Avoid It:

  • Compare mileage records on the vehicle history report.
  • Have a trusted mechanic inspect the vehicle if you suspect tampering.


5 Tips to Prevent Car Buying Scams

Spotting scams is half the battle—preventing them is just as important. Here’s how you can safeguard yourself throughout the car-buying process:


1. Do Your Research

  • Investigate the vehicle’s make and model, average market price, and reviews.
  • Research the seller’s reputation, whether it’s an individual or a dealership.


2. Insist on Meeting in Person

Whenever possible, meet the seller in a public, safe location to inspect the car in person. Test drives and face-to-face interactions will provide peace of mind.


3. Verify the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN)

Before committing, run the VIN using a reputable service like Carfax. This will reveal the car's history, including accidents, title issues, and mileage discrepancies.


4. Avoid Rushed Decisions

Scammers thrive on urgency. If the seller pressures you to make quick decisions or payments, it’s a warning sign. Take the time to verify the vehicle's condition and the transaction's legitimacy.


5. Consult an Expert

Bring a trusted mechanic or car-savvy friend to inspect the vehicle. They can identify potential issues and ensure everything checks out.


What to Do if You Encounter a Scam

Suspect you’ve encountered a scam? Here’s what to do:


  • Cease Communication: Immediately stop responding to the scammer.
  • Report the Incident:
  • Report online car purchase scams to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
  • If the scam occurred through a marketplace like Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace, report it to their respective platforms.
  • For fraudulent escrow services, contact the Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3).
  • Educate Others: Share your experience to help others avoid falling victim to similar schemes.


Making Car Buying Safe, Simple, and Enjoyable

Buying a car—whether it’s your first or your fifth—should be an exciting and rewarding experience. By staying alert, informed, and proactive, you can easily spot red flags and avoid car buying scams.

At the heart of your car-buying experience should be confidence. By knowing the warning signs and following the tips outlined above, you’ll have the tools you need to protect yourself, make informed decisions, and drive off with a car you can trust.


Want more car-buying tips and insider guides? Subscribe to our newsletter for updates and resources designed to keep you one step ahead in the car-buying game!